Speaker summary
⁠35%9 analyzed articles/videos907.5 analyzed words
BS Summary: These Malcolm McHaffie results contain 10 faulty reasoning types, including Quote-first Misdirection, Negativity Bias, and Confirmation Bias, with Appeal to Authority as the most egregious example at 29.9% saturation with 351 hits. Analysis detected 847.814 faulty-reasoning hits from 907.5 analyzed words across 9 articles, generating a BS Score of 7.5% and a BS Rank of ⁠7% (26,539 of 28,364 speakers). This Malcolm McHaffie is better (less manipulative) than 93.60% of the peer group.

Ranking context

Position among analyzed speakers

6% percentile
02550751006.4% percentile
7.5% BS Score9 analyzed videos907.5 analyzed words

Reasoning profile

Selected profile versus the sitewide rate

SpeakerSitewideShared scale 0–50%
0.0%10%20%30%40%50%Framing EffectSitewide 26.9%Speaker 4.1%4.1%Appeal to AuthoritySitewide 11.1%Speaker 29.9%29.9%Quote-first MisdirectionSitewide 0.0%Speaker 11.5%11.5%Negativity BiasSitewide 19.2%Speaker 7.8%7.8%IndoctrinationSitewide 0.0%Speaker 3.8%3.8%Confirmation BiasSitewide 7.5%Speaker 4.6%4.6%Ambiguity (Equivocation)Sitewide 0.8%Speaker 2.8%2.8%Biased Writer VoiceSitewide 5.3%Speaker 4.0%4.0%Unattributed QuoteSitewide 1.1%Speaker 2.3%2.3%Anchoring BiasSitewide 4.0%Speaker 4.2%4.2%

Sitewide departure map

Above the diagonal means this profile uses the pattern more often

0.0%0.0%10%10%20%20%30%30%40%40%50%50%Appeal to Authority: Speaker 29.9%, sitewide 11.1%Framing Effect: Speaker 4.1%, sitewide 26.9%Negativity Bias: Speaker 7.8%, sitewide 19.2%Quote-first Misdirection: Speaker 11.5%, sitewide 0.0%Confirmation Bias: Speaker 4.6%, sitewide 7.5%Biased Writer Voice: Speaker 4.0%, sitewide 5.3%Anchoring Bias: Speaker 4.2%, sitewide 4.0%Indoctrination: Speaker 3.8%, sitewide 0.0%Ambiguity (Equivocation): Speaker 2.8%, sitewide 0.8%Unattributed Quote: Speaker 2.3%, sitewide 1.1%Appeal to AuthoritySitewide rateSpeaker rate

Analyzed articles and videos

Andrew and Tristan Tate face UK extradition: What to know⁠28%
Yahoo News⁠39%By Will Carless⁠45% Kim Hjelmgaard⁠46% USA TODAY⁠13%7/19/2026, 8:45:08 AM
Andrew and Tristan Tate Arrested in Miami, Await Extradition to U.K. on New Rape Charges⁠4%
Rolling Stone⁠40%By Daniel Kreps⁠19%7/19/2026, 7:01:49 AM
Manosphere Influencers Andrew Tate & Brother Tristan Arrested In Miami In Connection To Sexual Offense Charges In The UK, Report⁠51%
Deadline⁠27%By Armando Tinoco⁠10%7/18/2026, 6:23:39 PM
Andrew and Tristan Tate arrested by US Marshals in Miami for UK rape charges⁠63%
The Independent⁠45%By Josh Marcus⁠57%7/18/2026, 6:07:32 PM
Andrew and Tristan Tate arrested in Miami amid new sexual offence charges⁠32%
The Independent⁠45%By Rob Freeman⁠0%7/18/2026, 5:57:47 PM
Tate brothers arrested by U.S. authorities, face additional rape charges in the U.K.⁠25%
NBC News⁠35%By Dennis Romero⁠0%7/18/2026, 5:28:45 PM
Influencer brothers Andrew and Tristan Tate arrested in Miami for rape and trafficking charges in the UK⁠46%
CBS Miami⁠19%By Ana Maria Soler⁠0%7/18/2026, 5:10:00 PM
Andrew Tate and Brother Arrested in Miami On Sex Crimes Charges⁠17%
Mediaite⁠70%By Jennifer Bowers Bahney⁠52%7/18/2026, 5:09:44 PM
Andrew and Tristan Tate arrested in Miami on charges of rape and sex trafficking⁠14%
The Guardian⁠81%By Guardian staff⁠41% agencies⁠23%7/18/2026, 4:57:34 PM