Speaker summary
42%29 analyzed articles/videos2,876 analyzed words
BS Summary: These Elena Kagan results contain 35 faulty reasoning types, including Appeal to Emotion, Pessimism Bias, and Appeal to Authority, with Post Hoc (False Cause) as the most egregious example at 11.5% saturation with 548 hits. Analysis detected 3,662.255 faulty-reasoning hits from 2,876 analyzed words across 29 articles, generating a BS Score of 2.6% and a BS Rank of 1% (27,727 of 27,841 speakers). This Elena Kagan is better (less manipulative) than 99.60% of the peer group.

Ranking context

Position among analyzed speakers

0% percentile
02550751000.4% percentile
2.6% BS Score29 analyzed videos2.9K analyzed words

Reasoning profile

Selected profile versus the sitewide rate

SpeakerSitewideShared scale 0–50%
0.0%10%20%30%40%50%Framing EffectSitewide 26.9%Speaker 3.1%3.1%Negativity BiasSitewide 19.2%Speaker 4.8%4.8%Appeal to EmotionSitewide 15.9%Speaker 7.5%7.5%Post Hoc (False Cause)Sitewide 3.3%Speaker 11.5%11.5%Appeal to AuthoritySitewide 11.1%Speaker 4.0%4.0%Availability HeuristicSitewide 9.1%Speaker 2.2%2.2%Hasty GeneralizationSitewide 8.1%Speaker 1.8%1.8%Halo EffectSitewide 6.7%Speaker 0.7%0.7%Quote-first MisdirectionSitewide 0.0%Speaker 5.1%5.1%Confirmation BiasSitewide 7.5%Speaker 2.7%2.7%

Sitewide departure map

Above the diagonal means this profile uses the pattern more often

0.0%0.0%10%10%20%20%30%30%40%40%50%50%Framing Effect: Speaker 3.1%, sitewide 26.9%Negativity Bias: Speaker 4.8%, sitewide 19.2%Appeal to Emotion: Speaker 7.5%, sitewide 15.9%Post Hoc (False Cause): Speaker 11.5%, sitewide 3.3%Appeal to Authority: Speaker 4.0%, sitewide 11.1%Availability Heuristic: Speaker 2.2%, sitewide 9.1%Hasty Generalization: Speaker 1.8%, sitewide 8.1%Confirmation Bias: Speaker 2.7%, sitewide 7.5%In-Group Bias: Speaker 2.2%, sitewide 6.9%Halo Effect: Speaker 0.7%, sitewide 6.7%Optimism Bias: Speaker 2.7%, sitewide 6.0%Biased Writer Voice: Speaker 0.8%, sitewide 5.3%Anecdotal: Speaker 1.8%, sitewide 5.2%Pessimism Bias: Speaker 5.1%, sitewide 1.9%Quote-first Misdirection: Speaker 5.1%, sitewide 0.0%Overconfidence Bias: Speaker 2.4%, sitewide 4.6%Slippery Slope: Speaker 4.5%, sitewide 1.7%Anchoring Bias: Speaker 2.7%, sitewide 4.0%Recency Bias: Speaker 4.0%, sitewide 2.7%Unattributed Quote: Speaker 3.4%, sitewide 1.1%Representativeness Heuristic: Speaker 2.6%, sitewide 1.9%Loss Aversion: Speaker 0.7%, sitewide 2.5%Hindsight Bias: Speaker 2.4%, sitewide 1.4%Ambiguity (Equivocation): Speaker 2.3%, sitewide 0.8%Framing EffectSitewide rateSpeaker rate

Analyzed articles and videos

Justice Kagan Rejects Charge that Supreme Court Is "Rubber Stamp" for Trump Administration32%
Reason.com42%By Jonathan H. Adler14%7/24/2026, 12:16:20 AM
Justice Kagan Says Don't Call It the "Shadow Docket"39%
Reason.com42%By Jonathan H. Adler14%7/17/2026, 12:54:16 PM
SC judges tell US Congress their safety is at risk and more be spent on security64%
The Times of India55%By Agencies22%7/15/2026, 3:47:00 AM
Supreme Court Justices give chilling accounts of threats to their safety25%
Iowa Public Radio30%By Nina Totenberg78%7/15/2026, 3:19:25 AM
Supreme Court Justices give chilling accounts of threats to their safety22%
KUAR19%By Nina Totenberg78%7/15/2026, 3:19:25 AM
Supreme Court justices detail security risks and weigh in on ethics in rare congressional testimony18%
Texarkana Gazette28%7/15/2026, 3:00:00 AM
Supreme Court Justices Tell Congress Their Safety Is At Risk And More Must Be Spent On Security30%
The Yeshiva World42%7/14/2026, 11:00:00 PM
Supreme Court Justices give chilling accounts of threats to their safety30%
NPR Las Vegas | Nevada Public Radio (KNPR 88.9)34%By Nina Totenberg78%7/14/2026, 8:19:25 PM
Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett says her son,12, asked why she had a bulletproof vest after Dobbs leak32%
New York Post89%By Josh Christenson78%7/14/2026, 4:06:59 PM
Justices tell Congress of threats to Supreme Court safety in push for more security30%
AP News54%By LUENA RODRIGUEZ-FEO VILEIRA12% MICHAEL WARREN8% JEFF McMURRAY32%7/14/2026, 2:57:19 PM